High Stakes for Trump’s State of the Union Address
Few of Donald Trump's speeches to Congress have carried as much significance as the State of the Union address scheduled for Tuesday night.
Throughout the past year, Trump has expanded the scope of presidential power in numerous directions.
He has secured notable achievements in both domestic and foreign policy arenas. However, not all of these accomplishments have been well-received; some have sparked considerable division.
Regardless of public perception, Trump will address an America markedly different from the one he returned to lead last year.
He has rapidly advanced his second-term agenda, focusing on stringent immigration enforcement and effectively sealing the border, disrupting foreign alliances, challenging foundational checks and balances within the American political system, and fundamentally redefining the presidency's role.
Nevertheless, he has encountered significant resistance from the public and key institutions that have limited his ambitions.
Opinion polls indicate a decline in public approval during his second term. A recent CNN poll showed only 36% of Americans approve of Trump's performance, while a Washington Post survey reported a similar figure of 39%. This State of the Union address offers Trump an opportunity to halt this decline at a critical juncture.
In just over eight months, voters will evaluate Trump's second term during the November midterm elections. They will decide whether to maintain the Republican majority in Congress or transfer power to the Democrats, which could result in legislative gridlock and intensified oversight, potentially leading to another impeachment, as Trump himself has suggested.
Tuesday's speech represents Trump's sole major opportunity to present his case to the American public before the elections, addressing millions in a significant event.
Trump’s Preview and Rhetorical Approach
On Monday, Trump previewed his intentions for the address.
"We have a country that's now doing well, we have the greatest economy we've ever had and the most activity we've ever had," Trump said. "It is going to be a long speech, because we have so much to talk about."
Robert Rowland, a University of Kansas professor and author analyzing Trump's rhetoric, noted that Trump typically boasts about his accomplishments while attacking perceived enemies and critics.
His previous congressional speeches, including last year's nearly two-hour address, have followed this pattern. However, Rowland suggests that at this "critical moment" for the president, a conventional Trump speech may not be the most effective strategy.
"State of the Union addresses are normally a time when the president does two things that President Trump essentially never does," Rowland said. "The president makes a case for his agenda. And they try to broaden the appeal of the agenda of the administration."
Much of Trump's second-term agenda and its promotion have targeted his political base. Expanding appeal often seems secondary to aggressive attacks. Yet, political realities indicate Trump must work to sell his agenda ahead of November.
Policy Challenges and Public Reception
Trump's decision to deploy federal immigration agents to cities such as Minneapolis was popular among party loyalists, who displayed "mass deportations now!" signs at the 2024 Republican National Convention. However, polls suggest many Americans believe these actions have gone too far.
The president's trade policies, including high tariffs on major American partners, have also remained unpopular. Last Friday, the US Supreme Court ruled that many of Trump's duties were illegal, casting doubt on the administration's trade regime.
Despite this, Trump has imposed new tariffs and pledged to expand their use, creating ongoing uncertainty about the economic and consumer price impacts.
While there has been some positive economic news, such as stock indexes near record highs and low unemployment, recent economic growth figures fell short of expectations.
Traditionally, the economy and immigration were areas where Trump enjoyed strong public support. However, his standing on these issues has declined since his return to the White House, contributing to his overall approval rating drop.
Immigration Controversies and Political Resistance
The deaths of two US citizens at the hands of immigration officers in Minneapolis sparked mass protests and led the administration to reduce the federal agent surge there, with Trump promising a "softer touch."
Efforts to build or acquire large new detention facilities have faced local opposition. Congressional Democrats have blocked Department of Homeland Security funding unless new legal protections for immigration enforcement are enacted. This impasse shows no signs of resolution.
Economic Messaging and Political Strategy
Last year, the White House indicated plans for a nationwide tour to promote Trump's economic record and present an agenda addressing public concerns about cost of living and "affordability"—issues Democrats leveraged in state elections.
However, the affordability tour has been sporadic, and Trump has not consistently adhered to the planned messaging.
Policy proposals such as capping credit card interest rates, increasing housing supply, and issuing "tariff refund" checks have seen limited progress. Although inflation has decreased from its peak during the early Biden administration, Americans have yet to experience the lower prices Trump promised during the 2024 campaign.
On Tuesday night, Trump may attempt to alter these perceptions.
Foreign Policy and Upcoming Elections
He could also justify the US military buildup potentially preparing for a strike on Iran—a foreign policy development that could unpredictably affect American politics.
At minimum, Trump's speech may reveal how he and Republicans intend to persuade Americans to support them in the upcoming elections.
"Normally, when presidents realise they are angering the public, they pull back and have some kind of mea culpa," Rowland said. "That's not something that President Trump ever does. I expect him to double down on the messages."
To take a different approach would require a trait Trump has seldom shown in politics—humility.
Follow the twists and turns of Trump's second term with North America correspondent Anthony Zurcher's weekly US Politics Unspun newsletter. Readers in the UK can here. Those outside the UK can here.
