Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Swinney Criticizes Burnham's Understanding of Scottish Devolution

John Swinney criticizes Andy Burnham's understanding of Scotland amid Burnham's plans to devolve power from Westminster and Holyrood. Swinney calls for sensible devolution and urges constructive engagement.

·3 min read
John Swinney, who is bald with glasses, in a close-up shot

First Minister John Swinney Criticizes Andy Burnham's View on Scotland

First Minister John Swinney has accused Andy Burnham of demonstrating a "lack of knowledge" about Scotland following Burnham's remarks suggesting that power is overly concentrated in Edinburgh.

Burnham, who is anticipated to succeed Sir Keir Starmer as prime minister, pledged earlier this week to devolve power away from both Westminster and Holyrood to foster prosperity throughout the United Kingdom.

The Labour MP described the Westminster system as "broken" and advocated for "radical" reform.

Swinney concurred that the UK Parliament is not functioning effectively for Scotland but emphasized that devolution must be approached "sensibly."

Burnham is expected to become prime minister on 20 July if no other Labour MP enters the leadership race.

Burnham's Leadership Pitch on Devolution

In a speech delivered on Monday outlining his bid for the Labour leadership, the former Greater Manchester mayor expressed his intention to "extend devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland by taking power deeper down."

"The people of Dundee and Bangor feel just as distant from Holyrood and the Senedd as they do from Westminster,"
Burnham stated.

Andy Burnham, who has dark hair, speaks with his right hand raised and his index finger pointing ahead. He is wearing a dark suit and t-shirt
Image caption, Andy Burnham is expected to become the UK's next prime minister

Swinney's Response in Glasgow

Speaking in Glasgow, Swinney said such comments highlighted "Andy Burnham's lack of knowledge of Scotland."

He underscored that his government is actively supporting local authorities and city region deals, ensuring that local authorities have increased control over their finances.

"Rather than sending us polemics from wherever Andy Burnham has decided to send us polemics from, he should engage constructively and also follow through on all of his rhetoric about making sure power is devolved out of Whitehall to different parts of the United Kingdom,"
the First Minister remarked.

Ad (425x293)

"And Scotland stands ready to take those powers and devolve them sensibly to grow and expand the Scottish economy."

The SNP leader noted that he has not spoken with Burnham since the latter returned to Westminster but expressed willingness to establish a "constructive relationship." He urged Burnham to act on improving living standards and to "empower" the Scottish Parliament.

"The test for Andy Burnham is whether there is going to be any reality beyond the rhetoric."

Scottish Government's Position on Burnham's Devolution Plan

The Scottish government has indicated it has "no idea" what Burnham's specific devolution proposals entail.

UK Energy Minister Comments on Burnham's Approach

UK Energy Minister Michael Shanks affirmed that Burnham intends to collaborate "in partnership" with SNP ministers to achieve "better outcomes."

The Rutherglen MP described Scotland as excessively centralised.

He told BBC Radio Scotland's Drivetime program that Burnham's plan involves transferring power away from Holyrood and Westminster to local communities who are best positioned to determine how funds should be allocated.

Shanks stated that devolution has not "always delivered," and some powers transferred to the Scottish Parliament "had not been properly used."

Questions Regarding Kate Forbes' Conference Attendance

The First Minister was also questioned about his former deputy, Kate Forbes, attending a conference featuring Nigel Farage, Boris Johnson, and several figures from the US right-wing.

Forbes, who stepped down from Holyrood following May's election, faced criticism from within her party for participating in the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship conference last week.

When asked if he would have spoken at the conference, Swinney responded:

"I certainly wouldn't speak at a conference like that because I'm going to have nothing to do with Reform."

This article was sourced from bbc

Ad (425x293)

Related News