Conservative Leader Kemi Badenoch's Campaign Efforts
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch made multiple visits to Aberdeen South during the final weeks of the by-election campaign, traveling to the city three times for photo opportunities alongside her Scottish counterpart, Russell Findlay.
She returned to Aberdeen Airport today to celebrate an unexpected Conservative victory over the Scottish National Party (SNP).
Badenoch's personal approval ratings have improved in recent months, yet the Conservative Party as a whole remains behind Reform UK in current polls.
Election Trends and Aberdeen South Outcome
Recent election results have shown a downward trend for the Conservatives, as evidenced in last month's Scottish Parliament and English local elections.
However, this trend was reversed today with the Conservative win in Aberdeen South.
The party invested significant resources into this seat, culminating in a comfortable victory for their candidate, Douglas Lumsden.
Performance in Arbroath and Broughty Ferry By-Election
In the other Scottish by-election held simultaneously in Arbroath and Broughty Ferry, the Conservatives finished second, narrowly ahead of Reform UK by fewer than 200 votes.
The SNP won this seat by a substantial margin, but the increase in Conservative votes indicates effective campaign organization from a party still recovering from previous setbacks.
Implications for the Next General Election
Looking ahead, a significant part of the electoral battle appears to be persuading voters to replace Labour MPs and positioning the Conservatives as a preferable alternative to Reform UK.
The Conservatives tested this tactical voting approach against the SNP in these by-elections and will likely view the results positively.
Specific Factors Influencing Aberdeen South
Several unique factors influenced the Aberdeen South outcome. Notably, former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell's recent guilty plea to embezzlement charges remains prominent in public consciousness. Murrell is scheduled for sentencing next week, and the ongoing repercussions have adversely affected the SNP's public image.
Additionally, Aberdeen is a central hub for the North Sea oil and gas industry. The Conservative campaign focused on the local job losses caused by the decline in offshore drilling, criticizing Labour and the SNP for their continued support of the net zero agenda.
This message may not resonate uniformly across the UK. Both the SNP First Minister and leading Labour leadership candidates have recently suggested expanding North Sea oil and gas extraction, indicating that other parties are adapting their positions.
Reform UK has also attempted to claim ownership of this energy policy debate but appeared more focused on the by-election in Makerfield than the Scottish contests.
Where energy policy intersects with the cost of living, the Conservatives seem to have captured public attention.
Labour's Poor Performance in Scotland
In stark contrast to the Makerfield result, Labour experienced a significant decline in Scotland, losing nearly 20% of their vote share in both by-elections.
For some within Labour, these results highlight the risks of entering future elections without a change in party leadership.
Warnings for SNP and John Swinney
Although the SNP retained Arbroath and Broughty Ferry and recently secured a fresh mandate in the Scottish Parliament, the Aberdeen South result serves as a caution for the SNP and its leader, John Swinney.
The two by-elections were triggered because SNP MPs elected to the Scottish Parliament had to vacate their Westminster seats.
One such MP, former SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn, has been appointed to Swinney's cabinet and is widely regarded as having leadership ambitions.
Following the result, Flynn tweeted it was "a tough night in Aberdeen that some will need to reflect on, quite heavily".
Flynn has not specified who he referred to in his statement.
Stay Informed
for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.
