Burnham’s Decisive Victory
Andy Burnham has achieved an emphatic victory in the Makerfield by-election, securing more votes than all his opponents combined. This result marks a significant moment for Burnham, who has long been a prominent figure in Labour politics.
While the Makerfield parliamentary seat has traditionally been held by Labour MPs for many years, the recent local elections had seen Reform UK dominate in this collection of towns south of Wigan, including Abram, Hindley, Orrell, and Winstanley. This context makes Burnham’s win particularly notable.
Burnham and his team have used this campaign to test an argument that is likely to gain traction in the coming days and weeks: that he represents the Labour figure capable of defeating Nigel Farage and Reform UK, unlike the current Labour leader, Sir Keir Starmer.
The emerging narrative suggests that Burnham’s popularity and ability to overcome Reform UK in Greater Manchester demonstrate his suitability as Labour leader and a potential prime minister.
However, it remains uncertain how far this appeal would extend beyond this region across the country.
The Significance of the By-Election
This by-election campaign and its results night were unlike any other. Having covered numerous by-elections, this one stands out due to its scale and implications.
A total of 77,478 voters were given the opportunity to elect a new MP, explicitly because one candidate, Andy Burnham, is positioning himself to become prime minister swiftly.
During the campaign, Burnham effectively campaigned against his own party’s record in government at Westminster, a remarkable stance to take.
Burnham’s Victory Speech and Ambitions
In his victory speech delivered late at night, Burnham implicitly outlined his ambitions, and collectively, his words were nearly explicit about his intentions.
"Tonight could be a turning point," he said. "This is a final chance to change," adding that this was a result that could "bring about a country that works for everybody."
Such statements are atypical for a by-election winner and indicate Burnham’s broader political aspirations.
Burnham is expected to appear before the media again later in the morning, although sources indicate he will not elaborate further on his wider ambitions beyond what he has already stated.
Prime Minister’s Response and Political Implications
The prime minister is also expected to respond to the result. While polls were still open, his allies were actively making the case that the national polling gap between Labour and Reform UK is not unusual at this stage of the parliamentary term.
They pointed to indicators such as net migration figures, economic growth, and increased funding for public services as signs that "things are turning around," according to a senior government figure.
However, the prime minister will face the reality of Burnham’s substantial victory when he reviews the results. It remains to be seen whether this will influence his outlook or his recent stance of defiance.
Should this result prompt more Labour members, from the cabinet and beyond, to call for Starmer’s resignation, it could signal that his leadership is no longer viable.
If no significant shift occurs and Starmer maintains his position, it will fall to potential successors, including Andy Burnham and Wes Streeting, to decide who will formally challenge for the leadership and when.
The coming days and weeks are expected to be politically dynamic and closely watched.
for our Politics Essential newsletter to receive top political analysis, insights from across the UK, and updates on major political developments. Delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
