Largest Increase in Tax-Free Allowance Welcomed by Manx Businesses
Manx businesses and pressure groups have expressed approval following the announcement of the largest single increase in tax-free take-home pay for workers in the Isle of Man's recent budget.
Outlined by the newly-appointed Treasury Minister Chris Thomas, the personal tax allowance has been raised to £17,000, representing an increase of £2,250.
This increase, which will cost the government £25 million, partly offsets a reduction in the proposed minimum wage increase to 5%. The original plan had been for a 9.9% rise, but this was scaled back after significant criticism from businesses and pressure groups.
Positive Response from Local Economy Forum
Chris Robertshaw, Chairman of the Local Economy Forum (LEF), described the increase in personal allowance as "totally positive." The LEF advocates for the interests of Isle of Man businesses and had previously warned against the proposed 9.9% minimum wage rise, citing concerns that businesses would struggle to absorb such a substantial increase abruptly.
The new tax allowance doubles to £34,000 for couples and is three times the amount originally planned in the budget prior to Thomas's appointment. This rise is expected to result in take-home pay comparable to what a 9.9% minimum wage increase would have delivered.
Robertshaw stated:
"We simply couldn't suppress the personal tax allowance any longer - it needed to go up in line with inflation.
The amount of tax over the last five years has shot up yet in no way has that resulted in reducing the deficit."
He argued that the general public, rather than central government, is better positioned to reinvest and stimulate the economy by having increased take-home pay.
"It's a totally positive situation. Today we've seen a solid step forward, seeing the treasury minister throw down the gauntlet.
We were going in the wrong direction before, with high taxation harming the wellbeing of the economy."
The timing of the fiscal changes has drawn scrutiny, as the rise is scheduled to take effect on 1 April, five months before the island's general election.
"It's late in the day," Robertshaw commented, "but it's a very positive change and definitely enjoys the support of the local economy and taxpayers generally."
Criticism and Concerns Over Cost and Minimum Wage Impact
Despite praise from the LEF, some Members of the House of Keys (MHKs) have criticized the move due to its impact on the island's financial reserves.
The LEF's concerns about the previously proposed near 10% minimum wage increase were echoed by the care sector, including Crossroads Care, which supports 500 islanders and employs over 120 staff members.
Jackie Betteridge, Chief Executive of Crossroads Care, expressed her views on the minimum wage:
"The minimum wage is something very close to our heart, we pay our staff the going wage but it has a knock on effect."
She explained that if a staff member receiving a carers allowance were to receive a pay rise, they might have to reduce their working hours to remain under the £210 weekly earnings threshold required to qualify for the allowance.
"I don't see how that helps the economy, it's not one size fits all," she said.
Betteridge noted that as a third sector organisation, the prospect of managing a significant wage increase and mandatory rises across all staff has been "worrying."
While welcoming the benefits of the personal allowance increase, she added:
"More people will have more money to spend how they need.
We haven't reached a panacea, but it's better than it was."
Additional Benefit Increases Announced
Alongside the personal allowance increase, Minister Thomas also announced inflationary rises in various benefits, including carers allowance.
Betteridge acknowledged this recognition of carers' contributions:
"Carers are real, they really are the backbone of the island's care system."
For further stories from the Isle of Man, visit the BBC website, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC , and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
